From network to proof: recommendation as verifiable information
This week's theme is "Recommendation as verifiable information". It starts from an article by Shane and Cable published in 2002 and asks a question of direct use to business leaders: how can a research idea be turned into a better funding method?
The research finding
Shane and Cable study 50 technology companies and 202 seed investors. They show that direct and indirect ties influence funding decisions through information transfer.
A useful recommendation does not create a social debt. It conveys information about the team or the project that the decision-maker considers credible.
What this finding does not allow us to claim
The study concerns technology seed funding in the United States. It does not demonstrate an identical causal effect on French public aid.
This limitation is important. It prevents us from presenting the relationship, the partnership or the governance as a guarantee of funding.
Application to complex projects
Ask third parties to document the facts they actually know, without turning their reputation into a substitute for evidence.
The number of signatures matters less than the fit between the author, the fact attested and the funder's uncertainty.
A steering question
A letter signed by a prominent figure impresses less than a precise message from a customer explaining the use they have in mind.
Which fact does your recommendation really make it possible to verify?
Conclusion
Shane and Cable's research does not offer an automatic formula. It helps to build a discipline: link each stakeholder to a specific piece of information, piece of evidence, resource or responsibility, then preserve traceability and the independence of the decision.
The corresponding worksheet: Worksheet: recommendation as verifiable information.
References drawn on: Shane and Cable (2002); Podolny (2001). Caveat: the study concerns technology seed funding in the United States. It does not demonstrate an identical causal effect on French public aid.