← All publications

Building the coalition: five functions before submission

A collective project brings together organisations that do not assess the same thing. A company examines delivery and the market, a laboratory scientific validity, a local authority territorial use, a public funder the relevance and additionality of its intervention. Building the coalition therefore takes more than gathering the right names: the work that connects their contributions has to be organised.

Diagnosing the uncertainty

Before mapping the stakeholders, the open question has to be formulated. Can the technology be demonstrated at the intended scale? Who will use the result? Which investments remain conditional? The diagnosis distinguishes a missing piece of information, an accepted risk and an incompatibility to be resolved.

This first function determines who the useful contacts are. It avoids asking for a letter of support from an organisation that should first provide data or run a trial.

Translating without distorting

Each partner has its own vocabulary and its own responsibility. A shared fact sheet can set out the facts that do not change from one contact to another: assumption, timetable, costs, indicators and expected evidence. It leaves room for different readings, while making disagreements visible. This is one possible application of the notion of the boundary object studied by Star and Griesemer, not an empirical finding about aid applications.

Translation is not an exercise in persuasion. It makes it possible to check that the parties really are talking about the same project and that no important constraint has disappeared in the rewording.

Combining resources

The project gains substance when dispersed knowledge and capabilities complement one another. A laboratory can test a technological barrier, a company organise industrialisation, a user verify the need and a private funder discuss the equity. Their value lies in the way their contributions fit together, not in their juxtaposition in an application.

Brokering work can also help a solution proven elsewhere to travel. This analogy must be tested under the conditions of the project, as Hargadon and Sutton's analysis of technology brokering suggests.

Coordinating decisions

For public funding, the sequence also matters: technical evidence, partner commitments and financial decisions must be compatible over time.

Governing

Who decides if the timetable slips? Who can commit their organisation? How does sensitive data circulate? Proportionate governance sets these rules before a disagreement imposes them in a hurry. The work of Provan and Kenis shows that the form of governance of a network is part of the problem, not just its composition.

The relationship with the assessor remains transparent, traceable and independent of any promise of a decision.

What CHOICE brings

Our advice connects the engineering of rules and budgets with the engineering of contributions and exchanges. Our research activity serves to formulate verifiable hypotheses, to distinguish mechanism from outcome, and to avoid attributing a success to a relationship too quickly. The coalition becomes stronger when everyone knows which uncertainty their contribution reduces and which document keeps a record of it.

The corresponding worksheet: Intermediation functions matrix.

References

  • Howells, J. (2006). Intermediation and the role of intermediaries in innovation. Research Policy.
  • Star, S. L. and Griesemer, J. R. (1989). Institutional ecology, translations and boundary objects: Amateurs and professionals in Berkeley's Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, 1907-39. Social Studies of Science.
  • Hargadon, A. and Sutton, R. I. (1997). Technology brokering and innovation in a product development firm. Administrative Science Quarterly.
  • Provan, K. G. and Kenis, P. (2008). Modes of network governance: Structure, management, and effectiveness. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory.