← All publications

Intermediation functions matrix

This resource helps to diagnose a project before approaching new partners. For each function, note an owner, a question to resolve, an expected deliverable and a review date. An empty cell signals work to be assigned, not necessarily a new stakeholder to recruit.

1. Diagnosis: which uncertainty is decisive?

Write down the assumption, its effect on the budget or the timetable and the test that could prove it wrong.

  • Deliverable: a framing note with the points still open.
  • Checkpoint: do we know which decision depends on this information?

2. Translation: which facts must remain identical?

Compare the versions of the project intended for the company, the laboratory, the local area and the funder.

  • Deliverable: a shared fact sheet with common objectives, data and definitions.
  • Checkpoint: does a form of words mask a real divergence?

3. Combination: which capabilities are complementary?

Link each contribution to the task it makes possible. An announced skill is not enough; specify availability, conditions of access and dependencies.

  • Deliverable: contributions matrix.
  • Checkpoint: what is missing if a partner withdraws?

4. Coordination: in what order should we act?

Put the trials, agreements, investment decisions and funding requests in order.

  • Deliverable: timetable of milestones and owners.
  • Checkpoint: does a commitment depend on evidence that will arrive too late?

5. Governance: who decides and who keeps the record?

Set the decision rights, the flow of information, the handling of conflicts and the confidentiality rules.

  • Deliverable: working rules proportionate to the project.
  • Checkpoint: does the procedure remain open and the assessment independent?

Using the matrix

Review the matrix when the scope, a partner or the timetable changes. Measure progress by the assumptions clarified and the decisions taken, not by the number of meetings.

This worksheet is a CHOICE proposal inspired by work on intermediation and governance. It is neither an official selection criterion nor a guarantee of funding.

The article behind this worksheet: Building the coalition: five functions before submission.

References

  • Howells, J. (2006). Intermediation and the role of intermediaries in innovation. Research Policy.
  • Klerkx, L. and Leeuwis, C. (2009). Establishment and embedding of innovation brokers at different innovation system levels: Insights from the Dutch agricultural sector. Technological Forecasting and Social Change.
  • Provan, K. G. and Kenis, P. (2008). Modes of network governance: Structure, management, and effectiveness. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory.