← All publications

From the literature

The intellectual property paradox

To encourage a company to invest in research, it must be able to benefit from the result. That seems obvious. But a difficulty arises immediately.

The more knowledge is controlled by whoever produced it, the less it is used by others.

Yet knowledge that has already been produced can often be used at very low cost.

This gives us one of the fundamental paradoxes of the economics of innovation.

Incentivise production or encourage diffusion?

Kenneth Arrow implicitly distinguishes two problems.

The first is producing knowledge. The second is using it.

To maximise the use of existing knowledge, it would have to be made widely accessible.

But to encourage someone to bear the cost of creating it, they must be allowed to derive a benefit from it.

The patent is one of the institutional responses to this difficulty.

It allows certain results to be appropriated temporarily.

But Arrow points out that no property system can make information perfectly appropriable. Knowledge circulates through imitation, through the mobility of people and through its use in other research.

An innovation never stands entirely alone

Another idea then emerges.

Knowledge produced today often becomes an input to tomorrow's innovation.

A piece of research may use the results of dozens of other studies.

The production of knowledge is therefore cumulative.

This is particularly evident in scientific research, but the phenomenon also exists in industry.

A company develops a technology on the basis of standards, publications, earlier patents, know-how acquired by its teams and technologies from other sectors.

It adds a new building block. That block may then become the input to another innovation.

The special case of fundamental research

This phenomenon becomes even more important the closer one gets to fundamental research.

Arrow observes that this type of research is likely to be particularly underfunded.

Why?

Because its direct economic value for whoever finances it may be low or extremely difficult to anticipate.

Its true value will sometimes emerge when it is combined with other knowledge.

And that combination may happen years later.

Fundamental knowledge therefore has a collective value that can be considerable, but which its producer does not necessarily manage to capture.

What this teaches us today

This helps explain why the innovation ecosystem does not rest on companies alone.

Universities, research organisations, companies, investors and public bodies play complementary roles.

Some knowledge is produced very far from the market. Other knowledge is turned into technologies. Still other knowledge enables industrialisation and then diffusion.

Between these stages, the financing mechanisms are not necessarily the same.

What this changes for the company

When a company builds its financing strategy, intellectual property should therefore not be treated as a mere administrative box to tick.

It is part of the business model of innovation.

Which knowledge should be protected? Which should be shared? Which building blocks come from partners? Which results will be reused in future projects?

In a collaborative project, these questions become even more important.

Financing, intellectual property and cooperation strategy must then be thought through together.

The real challenge is not choosing between protecting and disseminating. It is determining what must be appropriated to preserve the incentive to innovate and what must circulate to make the next innovation possible.

Main reference: Kenneth J. Arrow (1962), Economic Welfare and the Allocation of Resources for Invention, in The Rate and Direction of Inventive Activity: Economic and Social Factors, Princeton University Press / NBER, pp. 609-626. The economic reasoning is attributed to Kenneth Arrow. The parallels drawn with contemporary public funding and CHOICE's work are an editorial perspective.