The matrix of useful interactions before submission
This resource helps to prepare a relationship map without reducing it to a list of contacts. It starts from the project's questions, then links each question to a legitimate player, an expected contribution and a verifiable trace.
1. Information
- Question to ask: what information is the team still missing?
- Possible players: scheme operator, competitiveness cluster, CCI (chamber of commerce and industry), local authority, technical expert, customer or partner.
- Expected trace: priority clarified, timetable confirmed, criterion understood or incompatibility identified.
- Theoretical basis: Granovetter (1973) on the bridging role of weak ties.
2. Evidence
- Question to ask: which important claim needs to be made verifiable?
- Possible players: customer, laboratory, industrial partner, independent expert or local area.
- Expected trace: data, study, trial, specific letter of interest, technical validation or description of a contribution.
- Theoretical basis: Podolny (2001) and Shane and Cable (2002) on information and credibility signals.
3. Coordination
- Question to ask: which contributions need to be aligned, and in what order?
- Possible players: project holder, partners, co-funders, adviser, laboratory, bank and investor.
- Expected trace: responsibilities, milestones, sequence of decisions, governance and handling of dependencies.
- Theoretical basis: Provan and Kenis (2008) on network governance.
4. Translation
- Question to ask: which of the other party's rationales needs to be taken on board without distorting the project?
- Possible players: business leader, researcher, industrialist, local authority, investor and case officer.
- Expected trace: tailored scoping note, explicit public benefit, understandable technical barrier and coherent financial trajectory.
- Theoretical basis: Howells (2006) on intermediation.
5. Integrity of the approach
- Question to ask: is the purpose of the exchange clear, proportionate and traceable?
- Checks: no promise of a decision, respect for each party's role, relevant information shared fairly, conflicts of interest declared and independent assessment.
This last line is not optional. It distinguishes legitimate coordination from undue influence.
How to use it
For each uncertainty in the project, fill in five fields: the question, the legitimate player, the expected contribution, the right moment and the trace that will make it possible to verify the result.
A map is useful when it reduces an uncertainty or organises a contribution. If a relationship answers none of the project's questions, it probably does not need to be called upon.
The article behind this grid: Useful networks, not networks of influence.
References used: Granovetter (1973, 1985); Podolny (2001); Shane and Cable (2002); Howells (2006); Provan and Kenis (2008). Caveat: the matrix is an operational synthesis by CHOICE.