Why fundamental research is the hardest to fund
A company generally finds it easier to finance a project when it can answer three questions. What product are we going to sell? To whom? When?
Fundamental research has precisely the bad habit of making all three answers uncertain.
And yet a large share of future innovations depends on knowledge whose commercial applications were impossible to foresee at the time of its discovery.
Kenneth Arrow explains why this situation is not exceptional.
It stems directly from the economic nature of knowledge.
Information that produces more information
Research has a singular characteristic.
Its result can be used as an input to new research.
One piece of knowledge produces another. Then another.
Arrow insists on this interdependence of inventive activities.
When research begins, several directions may seem possible.
As new information emerges, some hypotheses become more credible and others can be abandoned.
Research therefore works as a succession of decisions. Each result changes the next decision.
At the outset, we know precisely less
This seems trivial. Yet it is fundamental to understanding financing.
The further upstream the project, the greater the uncertainty generally is.
The options are many. The final applications are still hard to determine. Future revenues are particularly speculative.
A company subject to profitability targets may therefore have good reasons to favour developments closer to the market.
This choice is rational at its own level.
But if every player makes the same choice, the economy risks producing too little fundamental knowledge.
Why fund several avenues
Arrow also offers a very interesting insight into how research works.
When uncertainty is high, it can be useful to explore several paths in parallel.
Gradually, the information accumulated makes it possible to rule out the least promising avenues.
This principle is almost the opposite of a classic industrial project logic, in which one seeks to select a single solution very early on.
In research, selecting too quickly can eliminate options before the information needed to genuinely compare them is available.
Financing therefore becomes sequential
This idea has a direct consequence.
It is not always appropriate to fund an entire programme immediately, as if its course were perfectly predictable.
Instead, one can fund a first phase designed to produce information.
This information then makes it possible to decide whether a second phase is worth launching. Then a third.
The value of financing therefore does not lie solely in enabling the project to be carried out.
It also makes it possible to buy information for deciding whether to continue.
What this changes for an innovative company
This logic can profoundly improve the way a roadmap is built.
Instead of writing: "We need five million euros to develop this technology", it may be more relevant to say: "We need a first phase to resolve three critical uncertainties. If the results are positive, we will be able to launch the next stage with a different level of risk."
The difference seems subtle. It is considerable.
The first formulation essentially presents an expense. The second presents a learning trajectory.
For highly innovative projects, the financing trajectory should follow the trajectory of uncertainty reduction.
Main reference: Kenneth J. Arrow (1962), Economic Welfare and the Allocation of Resources for Invention, in The Rate and Direction of Inventive Activity: Economic and Social Factors, Princeton University Press / NBER, pp. 609-626. The economic reasoning is attributed to Kenneth Arrow. The parallels drawn with contemporary public funding and CHOICE's work are an editorial perspective.