From Kenneth Arrow to today: funding a trajectory rather than a certain outcome
We began this series with a simple question. Why does innovation benefit from specific funding mechanisms?
After seven articles devoted to Kenneth Arrow, we can put forward an answer.
Because innovation combines three properties that are particularly difficult for a market.
It is uncertain. It produces information that is hard to appropriate. And part of the value created may benefit players who did not finance its production.
Arrow concludes that an economy based solely on private decisions tends to underinvest in research and invention, particularly in the most fundamental activities.
But public money does not magically solve the problem
This is what makes his analysis interesting.
Arrow does not stop at the sentence: "There is a market failure, so the State must pay."
He immediately shows that public funding also runs into difficulties.
How should projects be chosen? How should risk be allocated? How can the right incentives be maintained? How can results that nobody can foresee be funded?
These questions have not gone away.
They still structure contemporary innovation funding.
Another way of looking at public support
Companies often perceive public schemes as a series of independent opportunities.
A grant here. A call for projects there. A European programme. Regional aid. Funding for a demonstrator.
This approach can lead to reasoning opportunity by opportunity.
There is another way of seeing things.
Start from the project. Identify the successive uncertainties. Determine the information needed to resolve them. Then allocate to each stage the most suitable resources and financial instruments.
An information trajectory
An innovative project rarely starts with the same level of knowledge as it has two years later.
At the outset, the company has a hypothesis. Then scientific proof. Then a prototype. Then experimental data. Then a demonstration in a relevant environment. Then industrial information. Then economic and commercial data.
Each stage changes the nature of the risk.
And each reduction in uncertainty can change the way the project becomes fundable.
What the company is building is therefore not only a technology. It is gradually building credible information about that technology.
The consequence for financing
It then becomes difficult to regard financing as a one-off operation.
A project may start with a high proportion of public funding because the technological risk is significant.
As uncertainties diminish, other funders may become more relevant.
Investors have more to go on. Debt may become an option for certain expenditure. Industrial partners may commit.
Financing evolves with the knowledge accumulated.
The role of a financing strategy
An innovation financing strategy is therefore not about stacking up the available aid.
It is about synchronising three trajectories:
- the technological trajectory
- the risk reduction trajectory
- the financial trajectory.
It is at this intersection that public schemes take on their full meaning.
France 2030 (the French national investment plan), the schemes of Bpifrance (the French public investment bank), European programmes, and funding from ADEME (the French agency for ecological transition), the Regions or other bodies are not intended to replace all other capital indiscriminately.
They can step in where the level of uncertainty and the collective benefits of the project make purely private financing insufficient.
What we take from Arrow
More than sixty years after its publication, Kenneth Arrow's text thus allows us to move beyond a purely administrative view of public funding.
An aid scheme is not just a rate, a ceiling, an eligible expense and a closing date.
Behind the scheme lies an economic question: what risk are we trying to make possible?
And behind the project lies a second question: what new information will this funding make it possible to produce?
This is probably the best way to conclude this series.
Financing innovation is not financing a certain future. It is financing a trajectory that gradually turns uncertainty into knowledge, and then knowledge into decisions.
Main reference: Kenneth J. Arrow (1962), Economic Welfare and the Allocation of Resources for Invention, in The Rate and Direction of Inventive Activity: Economic and Social Factors, Princeton University Press / NBER, pp. 609-626. The economic reasoning is attributed to Kenneth Arrow. The parallels drawn with contemporary public funding and CHOICE's work are an editorial perspective.