Useful networks, not networks of influence
When a business leader talks about networks in the context of public funding, the word can cause unease. It can evoke privileged access, favouritism or the pursuit of influence over the decision. This confusion prevents us from seeing the legitimate and often indispensable function of relationships in complex projects.
What embeddedness means
In his 1985 article, Mark Granovetter explains that economic action is embedded in social relations. Organisations do not make their decisions in a vacuum. They draw on information, habits, reputations and coordination mechanisms produced by their interactions.
This framework does not mean that a relationship determines a decision. It means that an economic decision cannot always be understood by artificially isolating the players from their environment.
Why this idea matters for publicly funded projects
An industrial, innovative, territorial or collaborative project brings several rationales together. The company pursues an economic ambition. The laboratory assesses a scientific barrier. The local authority examines the wider benefits. The industrial partner looks at delivery capacity. The investor weighs risk and potential. The case officer must assess eligibility, additionality and the coherence of the funding.
The information needed is therefore distributed. An application can bring these elements together, but it does not produce them on its own.
The network as an information channel and a credibility signal
In 2001, Podolny distinguished two functions of networks. They can act as pipes that carry information and as prisms that influence how a player is perceived. In 2002, Shane and Cable showed, in the context of the financing of young US technology companies, that direct and indirect ties influence decisions through the transfer of information.
These findings should not be mechanically transposed to French public funding. They do, however, help explain why a legitimate third party can reduce uncertainty. A customer can confirm a use. A laboratory can document a technical hypothesis. A partner can specify its delivery capacity.
The translation function
Players do not naturally speak the same language. In 2006, Howells described the innovation intermediary as a player who diagnoses, translates, connects, negotiates and combines knowledge.
This function is central in complex projects. The intermediary's role is not to add a contact. It is to enable different players to understand the same project, identify their contribution and coordinate their commitments.
Legitimate networks, transparent lobbying and undue influence
Three situations must be distinguished.
A legitimate network conveys information, facilitates coordination and produces verifiable commitments.
Legitimate lobbying defends an interest transparently, within the framework of the applicable rules.
Favouritism, influence peddling and the concealment of conflicts of interest are of a different nature. They must be ruled out.
The quality of a relationship strategy is therefore measured by its traceability: the purpose of the exchanges, the role of each party, the fair circulation of relevant information and the preservation of an independent assessment.
Conclusion
A useful network does not replace the application. It helps to build the information, evidence and contributions that an application must make legible.
The question is not who can influence the decision. It is which system of players must make the project sufficiently clear, demonstrated and coordinated for an independent decision to be taken.
Use with: The matrix of useful interactions before submission and Building a useful network in seven steps.
References used: Granovetter (1985); Podolny (2001); Shane and Cable (2002); Howells (2006). Caveat: findings from US venture capital are not transposed quantitatively to French public funding.